What happens when you discover your partner is having an affair? Does how you find out have an impact on how you deal with it? Or do you want to know all the intricate details of who, when, where and how often?
The main question I see time and again in my clinical practice is: why?
Let’s start from when you first make a commitment to your partner to be exclusive. Regardless of whether that happens on your second date or when you’re well into the relationship, there’s a point, spoken or otherwise, when you both make a choice to commit to one another. With many couples this is a topic rarely discussed. Instead, you slip into an unconscious, unspoken assumption that neither of you will seek love, sex or any other form of physical or emotional comfort from another person in an intimate way. Trust is a given.
There are few things more devastating to a relationship than having that trust broken. Once trust between two people is ruptured, regardless of how long you’ve been together or whether you’re married or cohabiting, it can take a long time and a great deal of effort to rebuild, and sometimes it isn’t rebuilt.
What happens in the immediate aftermath of discovering an affair, or being discovered, can shape what happens next in the relationship. The partner who has had the affair may feel shame or guilt at being found out and may lie or minimise what happened to ease that shame. Some avoid the subject in the hope of quick forgiveness; others become defensive or blame their partner to deflect from their own actions.
The injured partner may feel betrayed and furious, moving between anger, hurt, disbelief and shattered assumptions about the relationship. They may want to know why, how, where, when and with whom, and sometimes that anger spills towards the other person involved. Most of all, they want to know the truth.
The culprit may initially feel relief that the affair is out in the open, quickly followed by fear and uncertainty about what happens next. Some dread being exposed to their own spouse or partner; others become anxious that they may now be expected to make a commitment.
The emotions that follow the discovery of infidelity can feel similar to grief. How each person responds will influence whether the couple rebuild their connection, remain together under a cloud of anger and resentment, or separate. But it isn’t always doom and gloom.
Julia called me after a couples counselling session to say she was relieved it had happened: she wanted out. Her husband’s infidelity was her ticket to freedom. She’d had years of being controlled and manipulated by her husband, who behaved like a tantrum teenager whenever she attended a work conference or went out with friends.
Peter and Sally decided to separate after Peter had an affair with a work colleague. They came for couples counselling because they wanted to manage the process as well as they could for the sake of their children. By the end of the first appointment, they realised they’d been neglecting their own relationship and wanted to work at repairing it rather than go ahead with a divorce.
Why do affairs happen?
There are familiar explanations for why people have affairs: lack of sex at home, loneliness, a longing for attention or intimacy, fear of commitment, or compulsive sexual behaviour. Any of these may be part of the story, but they don’t tell us everything about what is happening within a relationship.
To understand why some people struggle to stay in a monogamous relationship, how we react when a trusted partner has had an affair, and why some of us are drawn to unavailable people, I like to go back in time and look at how we learned to be in relationships in the first place.
What we learn about closeness
Our early relationships with parents or primary caregivers shape what closeness, trust and independence come to mean to us. When those relationships feel secure and loving, we learn that other people can usually be trusted and that closeness is safe. When care is inconsistent, chaotic or frightening, we may become alert to rejection and unsure whether love can be relied on. When caregivers are distant, unresponsive or strict, relying on ourselves can feel safer than depending on someone else. We can carry these expectations into adult relationships, especially when we’re stressed, anxious or angry.
Someone who feels secure in closeness isn’t immune to an affair. A friendship, often with a work colleague, can gradually cross a boundary that once seemed clear. If it comes to light, the ability to stay with a partner’s hurt, take responsibility and look honestly at what happened can make repair possible.
When closeness has felt uncertain, the pattern can look different. Someone may long for intimacy and reassurance but struggle to trust that they are loved, or believe they have to be perfect to keep that love. If they have an affair, secrecy and denial can become ways of postponing the rejection they fear. Once the affair is discovered, shame can make honesty difficult at precisely the moment their partner most needs it.
When independence has been the safer position, intimacy can carry its own threat. Someone may pull away when they feel controlled, suffocated or too exposed, or be drawn to relationships that allow closeness at a distance. If an affair is exposed, anger or withdrawal can become a way of protecting against feelings they have spent years keeping at arm’s length.
These patterns don’t tell us in advance whether a relationship will survive. Repair is rarely quick, and knowing someone’s attachment history doesn’t tell us what they will do next. What it can offer is a way of understanding why honesty, closeness, rejection or independence become so charged when the relationship is under pressure.
Infidelity can be a catalyst for change: it can destroy relationships, rejuvenate them or create new ones. Whichever way it moves, the relationship won’t be the same again.
Carla Devereux supports individuals and couples through a therapy process to help change patterns and transform relationships either in person or through the 2Truths self-paced programmes.
For more information email info@carladevereux or call 0121 745 9044.
Change what happens next.